Dropdown button for navigation mobile view

Income tax consequences of holding US visas

Posted by: Zaher Fallahi
Posted On: Nov 06, 2015

Newcomers to the United States on temporary visas may be unpleasantly surprised at the income tax consequences of their legal status. Advance planning with tax and immigration professionals can go a long way towards mitigating income taxes due.

 

Many countries impose taxes on income earned in that country (i.e., a territorial tax system). The US often imposes taxes on income earned in the US and outside of the US (a worldwide tax system). US residents and nonresident aliens are taxed differently. The definition of resident/nonresident is different for US income tax than for US immigration purposes.

 

The foreign nationals temporarily present in the US can find themselves paying US income tax on income received abroad, such as proceeds from the sale or rental of a former home after relocation to the US, or the sale of stocks, bonds or other assets acquired before the US assignment began.

For US immigration purposes, lawful permanent residents are issued alien registration cards commonly known as “green cards.”  US immigration law more broadly defines an immigrant as any alien in the US, except if legally admitted under specific nonimmigrant visa categories. Therefore, an alien unlawfully present in the US falls within the statutory definition of an immigrant or resident under US immigration law.

 

US income tax law is generous in bestowing resident status. Why? Because the US taxes residents on income earned worldwide and not just on income earned in the US. Resident aliens generally must follow the same tax laws as US citizens and report their worldwide income from all sources, regardless of whether earned in the US or outside the US. This can have expensive income tax consequences, especially for individuals with substantial income earned from sources overseas in countries that impose little or no tax on such income.

 

Who is a US resident for income tax purposes?

The IRS generally considers an alien to be a US resident for income tax purposes if either of the following two tests are met for the calendar year:

Generally, any day in which even a fraction of time is spent in the US is counted as an entire day in the US. That said, certain days are not counted, including:

“Exempt individual” refers to the US immigration status held on the days in the US. Although in fact physically in the US, the days will not be counted if the individual holds:

 

Impact of income tax treaties between the US and other countries

Treaties between the US and certain other countries sometimes allow US tax residents to be taxed at a reduced rate or be exempt from US income taxes on certain types of income. The US has such treaties with many countries. IRS Publication 901 lists the countries that have income tax treaties with the US and the applicable tax rates and exemptions.

 

The impact of the income tax treaty between Canada and the US, for example, generally is based on the individual’s tax resident status. A person who is a US tax resident and has income from sources in Canada will often pay less income tax to Canada on that income. Other special provisions under the US–Canada income tax treaty include provisions that Canadian source interest income received by US tax residents may be exempt from Canadian withholding tax, and Canadian source dividends received by US tax residents are generally subject to no more than a 15 percent Canadian withholding tax.

Also, gains from the sale of personal property by a US tax resident having no permanent establishment in Canada are exempt from Canadian income tax, but gains realized by US tax residents on Canadian real property and on personal property belonging to a permanent establishment in Canada are subject to Canadian income tax.

 

Treaty provisions vary country by country. The income tax treaty between the US and China includes an exemption from US tax for scholarship income (plus up to US$5,000 of wages per year) received by a Chinese student temporarily present in the US. Although under US tax law, a student visa holder may become a resident alien for US tax purposes if the temporary stay in the US exceeds five calendar years, the US–China income tax treaty allows this exemption from US tax to continue even after the Chinese student becomes a US tax resident.

It is important to note that many of the states in the US have state income tax. Some state income tax laws recognize US federal tax treaties, but some do not, including Alabama, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Maryland, Mississippi, Montana, New Jersey, North Dakota, and Pennsylvania.

 

Breaking the tie to determine tax residence

Many US tax treaties also contain tie-breaker rules for determining the tax residence of an individual who is otherwise treated as a tax resident of both the US and a treaty partner under each country’s internal laws (i.e., a dual-resident taxpayer). Generally, under these rules, an individual with a permanent home available in only one of the two treaty countries will be deemed resident in that country. If the alien has a permanent home available in both countries or neither country, a series of other factors are considered (e.g., center of vital interests, habitual place of abode and nationality). Generally, if no factor breaks the tie, residence is determined by mutual agreement.

 

Thus, depending on the applicable tax treaty, it is possible that a green card holder who has a home and center of vital interests in a foreign country may be treated as a nonresident alien of the US. The risk of claiming this tax treaty benefit is that it could compromise an individual’s future US immigration status (i.e., it may affect a green card holder’s ability to continue to qualify for the green card).

 

Besides tax treaties, even individuals who fall under the substantial presence test may still claim nonresident tax status if they are present in the US for less than 183 days in the current year, maintain a tax home in the foreign country during the year and can show a closer connection to a foreign country.

The “closer connection” test requires showing that the individual has more significant ties to a foreign country than the US. The IRS considers the following factors:

The closer connection test will not apply if the individual has applied or taken steps during the year to change status to a lawful permanent resident, including a pending application for adjustment of status to lawful permanent resident.

 

In addition, there are other US immigration activities that the IRS will consider as indications of intent to change status to a US resident. These include the filing of an immigrant visa petition or alien employment certification application.

 

Note that for US gift and estate tax purposes, resident status is based on a different concept—domicile, which should also be considered when making plans before relocation.

 

Zaher Fallahi, Esq., CPA, is a Tax Relief Lawyer, practices as Los Angeles Tax Defense Attorney and Orange County Tax Defense Attorney, and assists clients in solving their IRS problems with respect to OVDP, FBAR, FATCA and tax audit.  Zaher Fallahi has been rated 10 out of 10 by Avvo  http://www.avvo.com/attorneys/90024-ca-zaher-fallahi-1955056.html . About 1.8% of the US lawyers are also CPAs, and Zaher Fallahi is one of them. Zaher Fallahi was named a top tax attorney in September 2015 http://www.ocbar.org/AllNews/NewsView/tabid/66/ArticleId/1631/Coast-Magazine-Names-OCBA-Members-Top-Attorneys.aspx  Telephones: (310) 719-1040 (Los Angeles), (714) 546-4272 (Orange County), e-mail taxattorney@zfcpa.com

Ali Fassih
Ali Fassih
1713124814
It's been an honor to know Zaher Fallahi, Esq for the past 49 years.He is one of kind in almost everything. His clients and friends are always his priority. In my long life, I have had the chance to be helped by many people. But ZaherFalahi is a distinguished personality that his professionalism helped me to succeed in life.And that's why I never hesitate to refer my family and friends for all their legal and financial matters to him.
I have had the pleasure of knowing attorney Zaher Fallahi for over 10 years in a professional capacity. Zaher is knowledgeable, diligent, capable and a conscientious attorney. Zaher has a strong reputation in his field - International Tax and Undisclosed Foreign Bank Accounts - and is a good person, in general. I highly recommend him for your legal needs.
Jack
Jack
1699943138
Mr. Fallahi's expertise was critical in helping me navigate my complex tax matter, and helping me resolve it successfully. I am very happy to have worked with him. He was very knowledgeable and had excellent service.
Seyhun F.
Seyhun F.
1698124160
I recently used Mr. Zaher Fallahi’s services for my International Tax and CPA requirements. He has extensive knowledge, remarkable competence, and maintains a highly professional approach. His confidence, diligent follow-up, excellent communication, and accessibility, even during the weekends, provided great comfort. I would highly recommend him to anyone in the need of assistance with international tax matters
Yasamin Khalili
Yasamin Khalili
1696386366
I had the pleasure of working with Mr. Fallahi to obtain an OFAC license, and I couldn't be more satisfied with the results. Mr. Fallahi displayed exceptional expertise in navigating the complex OFAC regulations, ensuring a smooth and efficient process throughout. Mr. Fallahi's attention to detail, professionalism, and commitment to my case were truly impressive. Thanks to Mr. Fallahi, I successfully obtained the OFAC license I needed. I highly recommend him for anyone seeking expert legal assistance in this field.
Yousef Salami
Yousef Salami
1678051820
Dear Dr Fallahi helped me with cryptocurrency and stock market which are my business . During last five years ago, Dr Fallahi and his extremely expert team helped me to make money through crypto taxes and also Mr Jon is knowledgeable and always gives me best advice ,Appreciate your support and kindness.Best regards.
Reza Shafiee
Reza Shafiee
1669154077
I am writing my experience of getting an outstanding advice and going forward with getting an OFAC Permission for a family member. It was done fast, accurate, and perfectly amazing. I would recommend Dr. Fallahi with the highest rating possible. Thank you.
Eric B
Eric B
1669073014
Mr. Fallahi handled filing my foreign inheritance tax return and FBAR international tax filings. He was unassuming, thorough, and responsive. He was available via text, email or call, daytime hours and after hours, weekdays and weekends. He made himself available to my schedule and went above and beyond to ensure my peace of mind. It was a pleasure working with him and someone I highly recommend.
Alireza Modafe
Alireza Modafe
1668394662
I have known Mr. Fallahi for more than five years and have been using his legal expertise for several tax and OFAC related cases. I have been very happy with his advice and the outcome of those cases. He is an excellent attorney and CPA, very professional, responsive, and caring. He goes above and beyond to ensure your peace of mind. I highly recommend him.
A B
A B
1668040092
We hired Mr. Fallahi for an international money transfer matter that required OFAC compliance. Mr. Fallahi was very knowledgeable about the matter and knew all the legal nuances pertaining to the money transfer regulations. He is very kind and responsive and answered all of our questions during consultation session and after it. I definitely recommend him to any one that needs legal help in the similar cases.
Lisa Williams
Lisa Williams
1667953700
We enjoyed working with Mr. Fallahi who is quite knowledgeable and assisted us with an international financial endeavor with great success. We highly recommend him.
Vahid Emadi
Vahid Emadi
1666799203
Mr Fallahi was a great help to me and my family. He is a very knowledgeable lawyer and knows the ups and down of the law about our case. He gave us an step by step direction and made this a very easy process.I have to mention that his staff in Costa Mesa were always polite and helpful.
Mr. Zaher went above and beyond for me. His fees are comparable to other attorneys in the field. Nothing extravagant. In addition I received a personal attention I did not from other attorneys I've worked with. He made himself available when he was out of the office and worked diligently to meet a crucial deadline for me even as a first time customer. I am happy to have found an attorney such as Mr. Zaher.
Hossein
Hossein
1640013657
A dedicated and expert attorney. He spends time with the client as much as needed to answer any doubt or to ensure the client has a peace of mind in his/her case status. I've had attorneys who wouldn't care what happened to my case until I reach out to them. But Mr. Fallahi is quite opposite. He always follows up with you as he has a commitment to his work.
Knowledgeable OFAC and Tax Attorney/CPAI consulted Mr. Zaher Fallahi for OFAC and International Tax Matters. He did a great job for me. He is a very knowledgeable Attorney,CPA. I needed the work completed over the weekend, which he did instead of waiting for two weeks. He followed up on the status of the case regularly and I felt assured that everything was going well. I recommend his services without hesitation.
Nahid Ariant
Nahid Ariant
1639612533
DR. Fallahi is one of the most experienced, trustworthy, and knowledgable professionals in the field. I contacted him for the legal service. He was super helpful during the initial consultation and patiently answered all my questions. His responses were always timely even during the weekends, which I really appreciated . I had a great experience with DR.. Fallahi and would highly recommend him to those who needs legal services!
David Jafari
David Jafari
1637004741
I have known Mr. Fallahi for more than 15 years. He has helped us with several matters involving tax consequences of various transactions from the perspective of a tax attorney as well as matters related to OFAC. He is well versed in his profession and we do not hesitate to go back to him for advice on these matters. I wholeheartedly recommend him.
Bijan Golkar
Bijan Golkar
1636589140
We used Mr Fallahi's OFAC services for an international fund transfer. He is very well-versed in the subject matter and provided invaluable advice. He was available to answer our questions at all time. We appreciate and highly recommend him.
X Chen
X Chen
1633383304
Mr. Fallahi is one of the most experienced, trustworthy, and knowledgable professionals in the field. Recently, I contacted him for the incorporation service. He was super helpful during the initial consultation and patiently answered all my questions. His responses were always timely even during the weekends, which I really appreciated for. I had a great experience with Mr. Fallahi and would highly recommend him to those who needs legal services!
Sarel Gaur
Sarel Gaur
1633004601
Great experience using incorporation services as an MD radiologist! Very professional and responsive attorney + CPA
Greg
Greg
1630268731
We and our CPA worked with Zaher Fallahi to resolve a tax issue with a very satisfactory result. We greatly appreciated Mr. Fallahi’s knowledge, professionalism, and guidance. He was very easy to work with. He took care to patiently explain every step that we took, and completed our project in a very timely manner. Although our tax issue was probably a minor one for him, we never felt that he was giving us anything but top priority. I would highly recommend Zaher Fallahi to anyone needing tax/legal assistance.
Babak Mohseni
Babak Mohseni
1629657993
Hi. About six months ago I contacted Mr. Fallahi in regard to the inheritance money that I was trying to transfer to US. I needed guidance on what the legal procedure to follow is in lieu of all the issues that exist because of the Iran sanctions by the US government.Mr. Fallahi was extremely professional, accessible at all times and provided sound and legal advise. He guided me in the right direction and mentioned all the legal documents that I needed to collect while in Iran. Once i got back to US, he drafted the legal document that I presented to my bank and proceeded with the transfer of funds.I was so pleased with Mr Fallahi's conduct that I got him engaged with my cousin to take care of his case.
Shadi Shiri
Shadi Shiri
1619307484
My husband and I have been Mr. Zaher Fallahi’s client for more than 5 years. Mr. Fallahi has been outstandingly knowledgeable and caring. He is a compassionate professional that You can trust and benefit from his excellent advice. We feel lucky to have him by our side. Wish you all the best Mr. Fallahi.
I have been lucky to have Mr. Zaher Fallahi as my CPA and Tax attorney for the last 5 years. He is very informative and helpful in providing insights and perspectives. Zaher is detail-oriented, trustworthy, confident, and extremely knowledgeable in tax laws. He always goes the extra miles to make sure his client is protected and well served. Zaher is the most responsive person through email, that I have worked with in my life. Having his support is a peace of mind and blessing.
Hossein F
Hossein F
1614790936
Mr. Fallahi is very knowledgeable and highly competent in the OFAC area. He helped me navigate my case with ease and confidence. He advised and explained the steps necessary for the best outcome and frequently followed up with me to ensure my case was progressing. He always responded to my questions in a timely and expedient manner even on weekends. He takes special care of his clients and provides a high level of service. I highly recommend him to my friends and family and anyone who needs legal advice.
Hamid
Hamid
1614702813
Mr. Fallahi helped me with an OFAC related case. He did a great job for me and I am very happy to have worked with him.He explained the details of the process and gave me valuable advice.He is very knowledgeable and always available and responsive, even on weekends.
Golenaz El
Golenaz El
1604919344
Mr. Fallahi is amazing! very professional, very responsive and easy to communicate with. My husband and I had several consultations with Mr. Fallahi and his advise and the way he does business is excellent. You can really trust him and his experience specially with OFAC.We are very thankful and looking forward to do more business with him.I would highly recommend Mr. Fallahi regarding international financial issues and OFAC.
One of the best Tax attorneys and tax professionals in California. I always enjoyed visiting his office to get feedback and advice about various tax issues. Mr. Zaher Fallahi is both a CPA and a Tax Attorney and that combination is very helpful...
Dr. Shadi
Dr. Shadi
1598718032
Mr. Fallahi impressed me with his extensive knowledge and experience as a top of the line professional during the initial consultation. He patiently gave me detailed advice and instructions and gained my full trust. He answered any follow up questions very promptly and within hours, even on the weekends. Moreover, he followed up on my case several times to ensure everything is going well. Since I was on a very tight schedule, he expedited the process and made all the documents ready in one day. My experience was very positive and I would highly recommend him to my friends and family.
P K
P K
1590722834
I have been Mr.Fallahi’s client for over 15 years and as a healthcare professional, Mr. Fallahi and his team have done an excellent job for my personal and corporate taxes and book keeping.During these uncertain times of COVID-19, Mr.Fallahi and his team-members have been there every step of the way to help me file and send my PPP-COVID loan application as soon as it became available and they informed me about the EIDL COVID19 in such timely manner that on April 23, I saw the sum being deposited into my account!Zaher and his team treat every client like family and I am confident that I have been in good hands regarding my business financials and optimized personal and business tax filing for the last 15+ years .
Poorya Kiani
Poorya Kiani
1587264313
I met Mr. Zaher Fallahi two times and received consultation and services. I found him a very knowledgeable and helpful lawyer. He supported me patiently and timely. I really appreciate his excellent services.
David Khorram
David Khorram
1527881180
Zaher Fallahi has been our business financial advisory for over 25 years. His team have assisted us with all bookkeeping and tax preparations. His advise has been instrumental in our business growth. if you are looking for the best and most professional in tax service for personal or your business needs Mr. Fallahi ( Zaher Fallahi, CPA, Attorney At Law ) and his staff are the most knowledgeable and experienced in the business. they are thorough, experienced, intelligent and up to date on anything tax and business law related , financial or business related. Highly recommended
Next Reviewsjs_loader
Request Consultation