IRS Targets Potentially Abusive Investment Fund Tax Strategies

What Investors and Tax Professionals Should Know
By Zaher Fallahi, Attorney At Law, CPA (California & Washington, D.C.)
Downtown Los Angeles | Orange County – South Coast Plaza
Introduction
The Internal Revenue Service and the U.S. Department of the Treasury have announced increased scrutiny of certain sophisticated investment fund strategies that seek to defer, reduce, or eliminate federal income taxes through complex financial transactions.
In Notice 2026-62 and Revenue Ruling 2026-20, issued September 29, 2026, the government addressed investment arrangements involving exchange-traded funds (ETFs), partnerships, derivatives, and other financial products.
These developments are particularly relevant to high-net-worth investors, investment advisers, fund managers, family offices, and tax professionals involved in sophisticated investment and tax planning.
The central concern is whether certain arrangements, although structured to satisfy the technical requirements of individual tax provisions, produce results inconsistent with the economic substance and intended operation of federal tax law.
1. IRS Challenges Certain Tax-Free ETF Conversion Transactions
One of the principal issues involves the interaction between Internal Revenue Code Sections 351 and 852(b)(6).
Section 351 generally permits qualifying transfers of property to a corporation in exchange for its stock without immediate recognition of gain or loss, subject to statutory requirements and exceptions.
Section 852(b)(6) provides favorable treatment for certain in-kind redemptions by regulated investment companies, including qualifying ETFs.
Some investment arrangements have attempted to combine these provisions to allow investors holding appreciated securities to exchange their portfolios for interests in ETFs with materially different investments without recognizing the built-in capital gains.
Under the arrangement described in Revenue Ruling 2026-20:
- An investor contributes appreciated securities to a newly established ETF.
- The ETF issues shares to an authorized participant in exchange for cash or other securities.
- Shortly thereafter, the ETF redeems the authorized participant’s shares by distributing securities originally contributed by the investor.
- The investor effectively obtains exposure to a materially different portfolio while seeking to avoid immediate taxation on appreciated securities.
The IRS concluded that, under the specific facts presented, the ETF served as an intermediary in what was substantively a taxable exchange.
Accordingly, the ruling treats the investor as engaging in a taxable exchange under Section 1001 with the authorized participant with respect to the contributed securities used in the redemption.
The ruling relies on established principles, including the substance-over-form and step-transaction doctrines.
Practical significance: Compliance with the formal requirements of individual Code provisions does not necessarily establish the tax treatment of a series of prearranged transactions when the transactions, viewed together, produce a materially different economic result.
2. Partnership Exchange Funds Also Face Scrutiny
Notice 2026-62 identifies related strategies involving partnerships and Section 721.
Section 721(a) generally permits property to be contributed to a partnership in exchange for a partnership interest without immediate gain recognition. However, Section 721(b) provides an important exception for certain transfers to investment-company-type partnerships.
The IRS describes arrangements in which investors contribute appreciated securities to partnerships that subsequently participate in ETF conversion transactions.
These arrangements may be designed to allow investors to diversify concentrated securities positions without recognizing capital gains that ordinarily would arise from taxable dispositions.
The Treasury Department and IRS are considering additional guidance addressing these partnership structures.
Importantly, the notice does not conclude that every partnership exchange fund is abusive. The tax consequences depend on the particular structure, transactions, and applicable law.
3. Box Spread Funds and Potential Conversion of Investment Income
Another area of concern involves funds using option-based strategies known as box spreads.
A box spread combines options positions to produce an economic return resembling a short-term interest rate.
The IRS is examining arrangements in which funds use in-kind redemptions to distribute appreciated options positions before expiration, potentially avoiding current recognition of income or gain.
In certain arrangements, investors may seek to defer taxation until they dispose of their fund shares, with the resulting gain potentially receiving capital gain treatment.
The notice also identifies strategies combining box spreads with offsetting positions that may generate deductible losses while related gains remain unrecognized.
These arrangements raise questions concerning the timing and character of taxable income, as well as the proper application of the relevant statutory provisions.
4. Dividend Timing and Fund Qualification Strategies
The IRS has also identified certain ETF strategies involving the timing of dividend distributions.
For example, a fund holding shares of another ETF may arrange an in-kind redemption shortly before the underlying ETF’s dividend record date. The fund may then acquire economically similar replacement investments.
The intended result may be to avoid current dividend income without materially changing the fund’s investment exposure.
Separately, the IRS is reviewing arrangements involving commodities, digital assets, and other investments that may produce income not qualifying under the regulated investment company income requirements of Section 851(b)(2).
Certain funds seek to avoid recognizing nonqualifying gains through in-kind redemptions, thereby attempting to preserve their favorable tax classification.
These concerns do not mean that ordinary ETF investments, conventional in-kind redemptions, or legitimate digital asset investments are inherently improper.
5. Tax-Aware Funds and the Character of Gains and Losses
Notice 2026-62 also addresses investment funds that use multiple financial positions to produce tax results that may differ significantly from their underlying economic returns.
Certain strategies seek to generate ordinary losses while producing corresponding capital gains, potentially allowing ordinary losses to offset income taxed at higher rates.
The notice discusses arrangements involving:
- Identified straddles and mixed-character financial positions.
- Foreign currency forward contracts.
- Selective termination of notional principal contracts.
- Other coordinated transactions involving the timing or characterization of gains and losses.
The IRS is particularly concerned with arrangements that appear designed primarily to generate favorable tax consequences rather than meaningful investment returns.
Nevertheless, the government expressly recognizes that established and legitimate tax-management techniques, including conventional tax-loss harvesting, may remain appropriate.
The distinction between legitimate tax planning and an abusive arrangement depends on the applicable law and the actual economic substance of the transactions.
6. Potential Retroactive Guidance and IRS Examination Risk
An important aspect of Notice 2026-62 is the possibility of further administrative action.
The Treasury Department and IRS are considering additional regulations, revenue rulings, notices, and other guidance. Certain transactions could potentially be identified as transactions of interest or listed transactions, which may trigger additional disclosure obligations.
The notice also acknowledges that future guidance could, where legally permissible, apply retroactively.
However, retroactive application is not automatic, and the scope and effective date of any future guidance will depend on applicable legal authority and the particular action taken.
Furthermore, the IRS may challenge transactions under existing law without waiting for new regulations or other published guidance.
7. Recommendations for Investors and Tax Professionals
Investors participating in sophisticated investment fund arrangements should consider reviewing their transactions with qualified tax and legal advisers.
Particular attention should be given to the economic purpose of the investment, the sequence of transactions, the contractual arrangements among participants, and whether the anticipated tax benefits depend on multiple coordinated steps.
Documentation should establish the legitimate investment objectives and economic characteristics of the transaction, rather than merely its intended tax consequences.
Investors should also evaluate whether previously completed transactions present potential examination exposure and whether future guidance could affect reporting or disclosure obligations.
Conclusion
Notice 2026-62 and Revenue Ruling 2026-20 reflect heightened federal scrutiny of investment strategies that seek favorable tax results through coordinated transactions involving ETFs, partnerships, derivatives, and other financial products.
The government has not rejected legitimate tax planning or conventional ETF operations. Rather, its stated objective is to address arrangements that exploit technical statutory provisions to achieve results inconsistent with their intended purpose.
For investors and advisers, the principal lesson is that a transaction’s legal form, economic substance, and overall structure must be evaluated together.
As these developments continue, careful legal and tax analysis remains essential.
Zaher Fallahi, Attorney At Law, CPA (CA & DC)
Downtown Los Angeles – U.S. Bank Tower
Orange County – South Coast Plaza, Costa Mesa
Tax Law | IRS Audits & Appeals | Tax Controversy | International Taxation
Primary Legal Authorities
- IRS Notice 2026-62, Guidance and Other Actions Being Considered Regarding Certain Potentially Abusive Investment Fund Strategies Involving Financial Products (September 29, 2026).
- Revenue Ruling 2026-20 (September 29, 2026).
- Internal Revenue Code Sections 351, 721, 851, 852, 1001, and 1092.
Disclaimer: This article is provided for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Tax consequences depend on the specific facts and applicable law. Reading this article does not establish an attorney-client relationship.